Hot topics close

Baroness in trans free speech row with pupil DEFENDS the student's right to disagree with her

Baroness in trans free speech row with pupil DEFENDS the students right to disagree with her
The peer embroiled in a row over an 18-year-old girl who was 'hounded out of her school for defending the right to question transgender ideology' has backed the teenager's right to disagree with her.

Baroness embroiled in free speech row with 18-year-old pupil who was hounded out of her school for questioning trans ideology DEFENDS the student's right to disagree with her

  • A-level student had been branded a ‘heretic’ for questioning pro-trans remarks made by the member of the House of Lords when the Baroness visited the school
  • Sixth-former was reportedly subjected to a verbal 'pile-on' by up to 60 students
  • Baroness said she felt she had parted on amicable terms with the unnamed pupil 

By Georgia Edkins Whitehall Correspondent For The Mail On Sunday

Published: 00:12 BST, 22 May 2022 | Updated: 00:13 BST, 22 May 2022

The peer embroiled in a row over an 18-year-old girl who was reportedly hounded out of her school for defending the right to question transgender ideology has backed the teenager’s right to disagree with her.

Britain’s ‘cancel culture’ crisis was pulled into sharp focus last week when it was claimed that the A-level student had been branded a ‘heretic’ for questioning pro-trans remarks made by the member of the House of Lords when she visited the school.

The sixth-former was reportedly subjected to a verbal ‘pile-on’ by up to 60 students after debating her views with the peer during a questions-and-answers session at the private school in the Home Counties.

Last night, the Baroness – who The Mail on Sunday is not naming to protect the identity of the student – said she felt she had parted on amicable terms with the pupil.

The peer embroiled in a row over an 18-year-old girl who was reportedly hounded out of her school for defending the right to question transgender ideology has backed the teenager’s right to disagree with her (file photo)
The peer embroiled in a row over an 18-year-old girl who was reportedly hounded out of her school for defending the right to question transgender ideology has backed the teenager’s right to disagree with her (file photo)

The peer embroiled in a row over an 18-year-old girl who was reportedly hounded out of her school for defending the right to question transgender ideology has backed the teenager’s right to disagree with her (file photo)

‘I spoke about a wide range of human rights issues,’ the peer said. ‘One young woman challenged some of my views and was treated with the same courtesy as everyone else who took part.’

She added: ‘I was not aware of any consequences from our interactions and thought that we had parted on amicable terms.’

Insisting the young woman had ‘the right to make her views known’, the Baroness joined politicians and advocates who have said the girl should have been free to argue her case

Among them is Harry Potter author J. K. Rowling, who last week condemned the ‘utterly shameful treatment’ of the sixth-former by students gripped by ‘quasi-religious fanaticism’.

The Baroness’s comments may bring some comfort to the 18-year-old, whose experience was highlighted by one of her teachers on the Transgender Trends website.

Yesterday, the girl told The Times: ‘It made me think I was mad. Otherwise how could people turn on me so bitterly?’

Education Secretary Nadhim Zahawi described the row as ‘hugely concerning’.

It is understood that the school disputes the version of events outlined in the media.

Similar shots
  • Bill Maher Uses Masked Paranoid World To Describe Covid19 Situation  Heres What Hes Got Wrong Again
News Archive
  • Bahrain GP
    Bahrain GP
    The laps that underpinned Verstappen's crushing Bahrain GP victory
    2 Mar 2024
    13
  • Israel Adesanya
    Israel Adesanya
    UFC 305 predictions -Dricus du Plessis vs. Israel Adesanya: Fight ...
    17 Aug 2024
    12
  • DJ Khaled
    DJ Khaled
    DJ Khaled shares video of his painful surfing accident
    14 Jun 2023
    5
  • LeAnn Rimes
    LeAnn Rimes
    LeAnn Rimes wins 'The Masked Singer' Season 4 as The Sun
    17 Dec 2020
    3
  • Austin Wolf
    Austin Wolf
    Adult film star Austin Wolf is arrested on charges of distributing child ...
    28 Jun 2024
    4
  • Seth Binzer
    Seth Binzer
    Crazy Town Frontman Seth Binzer, Known as Shifty Shellshock ...
    25 Jun 2024
    4
This week's most popular shots