Cardinals Trade Isaiah Simmons To New York Giants For Draft Pick

EAGAN, Minn. -- The Cardinals never could figure out where to play Isaiah Simmons, but that isn't their responsibility anymore.

Simmons was traded to the New York Giants on Thursday morning for a seventh-round pick in 2024, a return that underscores where Simmons' status has fallen after he was a first-round pick -- the eighth overall -- in 2020. The deal won't be complete until Simmons passes a physical, although that is expected.

"I don't think it was an issue of what Isaiah did, he did everything that we asked him to do," coach Jonathan Gannon said. "Moving forward we feel this is the best way we want to play football against other people. We're going to try and put the best guys out there that can function and do the best job."

Simmons was an athletic freak who was drafted by previous GM Steve Keim to be a rangy inside linebacker in the mold of former Pro Bowler Daryl Washington. He also had the ability to move around the field as needed.

But Simmons never quite took to the position -- he struggled to cover tight ends, one of the things both he and the Cardinals believed would be a strength -- and last season, he was playing slot cornerback more than anywhere else. Simmons flashed at times, with a game-turning interception against the Seahawks in 2020 and a forced fumble against the Raiders in 2022, both in overtime, but the consistency was never there.

When the Cardinals changed coaches, defensive coordinator Nick Rallis moved Simmons to safety, with the idea Simmons' athleticism would give the team a rangy, physical playmaker in the back. But it also meant one of the defense's best players, Jalen Thompson, was going to have to play nickel more than safety.

Simmons' last look from the Cardinals came against the Chiefs in last week's preseason loss, a game in which SImmons got lost in coverage a couple of times and also overran a potential hit on a QB run by the Chiefs' Shane Buechele on a touchdown.

"We have talked to a lot of teams about different players," GM Monti Ossenfort said. "The situation presented itself (Thursday) morning and where we are as a team and where we are in camp, we felt like this is the right move for us to make."

Ossenfort said the Chiefs game was not the spark for the trade.

"With all these decisions, it's a culmination," Ossenfort said. "We won't make a snap judgement on one game or one play or anything like that. It's a culmination of since we all got here, in the spring, in camp and a decision we came to, and not a reaction."

Simmons is scheduled to become a free agent after the 2023 season, after the Cardinals had declined to pick up his fifth-year option for 2024 earlier this year. His salary is $1.01 million for 2023.

The Giants visit the Cardinals for the Cards' home opener in Week 2.

The Cardinals now have 12 picks in next year's draft, although Ossenfort said that wasn't the point of the deal and Gannon also emphasized moves now are about 2023.

"We are obviously trying to win games," Gannon said. "And doing what we can to win games. The picks and all that stuff, I don't handle that stuff. We felt like it was a good decision, and we move on."